As a therapist, I frequently encounter children, adolescents, and adults who struggle to understand their own behaviour, manage emotions, or feel secure in relationships. One recurring pattern I see – often quietly embedded in family dynamics – is a form of parenting where behaviour change is driven almost exclusively by punishment or material rewards, with little reliance on affirmative strategies such as co-regulation, praise for effort, or general validation. The result? Children, adolescents, and adults who feel either in trouble or bribed – with little room for internal motivation or secure attachment.
Punishment and Dopamine: A False Binary
In this dynamic, parents tend to rely heavily on punitive interventions: Grounding, timeouts, yelling, or withdrawal of privileges when the child behaves undesirably. When the child complies or shifts behaviour, instead of receiving relational or affirming feedback, they are rewarded with gifts, screen time, treats, or other dopamine-based incentives. Rarely is there space carved out for acknowledgment of collaboration in problem-solving, effort, or emotion-focused dialogue.
This system often operates unconsciously, and it is easy to see how it develops. Many caregivers are themselves products of similar dynamics and may lack models for emotionally attuned parenting. Yet the unintended impact is profound.
A Child’s Experience: Either in Trouble or Being Bought
From the child’s perspective, this binary leaves them in a confusing emotional loop:
- “When I mess up, I’m punished.”
- “When I behave, I get stuff.”
- “When I try to do the right thing on my own, it’s barely noticed.”
This undermines their ability to build intrinsic motivation – the drive to do well because it feels right, not just because it avoids punishment or earns a reward. Over time, children in this pattern stop responding to affirmative discipline. It feels unfamiliar, even suspicious. Their emotional world becomes conditioned to external motivators, not internal understanding.
The Long-Term Impact
Children raised in these dynamics often show signs of:
- Emotion dysregulation – difficulty managing feelings without external triggers.
- Low self-worth masked by performance – feeling “good” only when they are pleasing others or earning praise.
- An external locus of control – believing that behaviour is dictated by outside consequences, not personal values.
- Avoidant or oppositional behaviours – resistance to relational influence, as it does not feel safe or consistent.
Therapists may notice that these children / adolescents / adults are hypervigilant, dismissive of praise, or overly dependent on incentives. In teens and adults, it may manifest as transactional relationships, testing boundaries, or seeking validation through material or social capital rather than secure connection.
The Adult Legacy: How This Pattern Echoes Later in Life
Adults who grew up with this dynamic often carry unresolved patterns into their personal, professional, and romantic lives. These may include:
- Chronic self-doubt and imposter syndrome: Without a foundation of stable, affirming feedback in childhood, these adults may feel their competence is always under scrutiny or dependent on performance.
- Difficulty trusting affirmative feedback: Praise can feel manipulative or disingenuous. Many adult survivors expect affection to be followed by a request or condition.
- Emotional avoidance or shutdown: Having rarely experienced co-regulation, these individuals may struggle to tolerate emotional vulnerability, especially when not tied to action or outcome.
- People-pleasing or perfectionism: A learned survival strategy, rooted in a belief that worth must be earned through compliance, achievements, or “being good.”
- Struggles with intrinsic motivation: Without internalized values or a sense of self-direction, adults may feel lost without external goals, deadlines, or incentives to define their behaviour.
- Transactional relationships: Adults may feel safest when relational exchanges are explicit and predictable – “I do this for you, you do this for me” – rather than emotional intimacy.
These patterns often surface in therapy as vague burnout, dissatisfaction, intimacy struggles, or difficulty accessing joy or rest without guilt. The good news is that these are learned responses – and can be unlearned within the safety of a reparative therapeutic relationship.
Restoring the Middle Ground: Affirmative Parenting as Repair
Healing this dynamic involves guiding caregivers toward affirmative, connection-based strategies. This does not mean abandoning structure or consequences – it means anchoring them in relationship. Strategies may include:
- Collaborative problem-solving – collaboratively setting limits and brainstorming solutions.
- Emotion coaching – helping name, understand, and manage feelings in real time.
- Non-material rewards – time together, shared rituals, or verbal acknowledgment.
- Process-focused praise – recognizing effort, persistence, and empathy rather than just outcomes.
By shifting the focus from behaviour management to relational development, we help families move away from the extremes of punishment and bribery, and toward mutual understanding and growth.
Final Thoughts
As therapists, we can normalize how common this pattern is – and empower caregivers to make small, meaningful changes. Children do not need perfect parents. They need present ones: Willing to show up, set limits with empathy, and celebrate progress rooted in connection, not control.
And for adult survivors of transactional parenting, therapy can offer a second chance to internalize worth, trust affirmation, and discover the power of being seen – not for what they produce, but for who they are.
—
You can listen to the audio version of this article below:
Want to know more about a specific topic related to psychotherapy? Send me an email (adam@cwcp.ca) and let me know so I can write a blog post about it. And if you would like an honorable mention for your recommendation, let me know that too and I will include your name!
